Skip to main content

About Our Agency

Finnicum Hometown Insurance Agency brings small-town values and builds trusted relationships.

Your trusted, small-town insurance agency—here for you.

Home » About Our Agency

For the nearly five decades we’ve been in business, Finnicum Hometown Insurance Agency has always been dedicated to our clients and our community. To this day, we bring the same personalized, small-town customer service from a team that gives back and supports our local community.

Finnicum Hometown Insurance Agency - Logo Icon

Who we are and where we’re going.

Welcome home to your small-town agency, Finnicum Hometown Insurance Agency. Located in the heart of Magnolia, OH, we are locally owned and operated by two award-winning insurance professionals who are here to help you. Owners Denise Baum and Trisha Dagenhard are driven to live up to the small-town values that the agency was founded upon by James C. Finnicum back in 1974. To this day, we are still dedicated to those core values of personalized service and building long-term relationships that truly change the way you experience insurance.

Finnicum Hometown Insurance Agency - Logo Icon

Why choose us?

As a local independent insurance agency, we represent a variety of insurance companies in order to help you find the insurance solutions you’re looking for. By getting to know you and working with you one-on-one, we make the insurance process simple from start to finish. In addition, you’ll be working with a team dedicated to our community through volunteering and giving back, because we believe in the people and organizations that make our community what it is. Let us help you with your insurance needs!

Our Mission

“At Finnicum Hometown Insurance Agency, we bring small-town values to insurance to form long-term relationships with our clients.”

Denise Baum

Principle Agent

Trisha Dagenhard

Principle Agent

About Our Agency - Close-up Group Headshot of Denise, Trisha, and Barabara

Get Started Today

As an independent agency, we are here to help you find the right coverage.

Get a Quote

The Advantage of an Independent Agency Working for You

What makes our independent agency different?

  • Personalized insurance solutions.
  • Friendly, knowledgeable service.
  • Building trusted relationships.
Find Out How

Get the power of choice when it comes to finding the right insurance for your situation. We offer a wide variety of policies and price points to choose from.


Rely on us to simplify the insurance process, from advising you on your risks and solutions, to advocating on your behalf to the insurance company.


Count on us to be there for you every step of the way with personable and professional service so you always have the right coverage for your insurance needs.

Award Winning Agents

We are proud to have earned prestigious awards in the insurance industry over the years, stemming from our commitment and dedication to serving our clients.

We’ve continually earned the Erie Insurance Founders’ Award since taking over in 2016, an award the previous owner, James Finnicum, also earned each year.

Trisha was awarded a lifetime Inner Circle Club membership with Pekin Life Insurance Company, an achievement awarded to only a handful of agents.

  Visit us in the heart of Magnolia, OH, right on Main Street. We are proud to serve the tri-county area of Stark, Carroll, and Tuscarawas County, as well as across Ohio with insurance solutions and service you can count on.

  Request an Insurance Quote

As an independent agency, we are here to help you find the right coverage.

  • Please do not include sensitive, private information in this area.
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Get a Quote

It only takes a minute to get started.

  • Fill out the form, we’ll be in touch.
  • Go over your options with an agent.
  • Get the coverage you need.

Would you rather discuss this in person? Get in touch with an agent today!